Joseph Muller grew up in Brooklyn, NY and went to Cathedral Prep, in Queens, NY, where he and Sean met. At Fordham University, he met his future wife, Jennifer, with whom he has two children, Sean and Keira. In 2006, he received his M.A. in Biblical Theology from St. John’s University and has since taught there as an adjunct professor, while he has also taught theology on the high school level.